I write a series for Slate called "Bad Advice," in which I take common but poor investment advice and explain why it's bad. One of my consistent themes is that, in most cases, the more you trade, the worse you do. The logic behind this is that, unlike investing, trading is a zero-sum game: every dollar "won" by one trader must be "lost" by another. (When you throw in transaction costs, moreover, trading becomes a negative-sum game: most traders lose.)
One Slate reader argued that this logic was bogus, that trading is NOT a zero-sum game, because if you buy a stock at $5 and it goes to $10, the $5 you make does not come out of someone else's pocket. The reader is missing an important distinction, but the response is common, so here's a longer explanation.
First, you have to draw a clear distinction between "investing" and "trading." Every market participant defines these terms differently, but, for now, let us say that "investing" means holding a portfolio of stocks for an entire period (any period--a day, month, year, decade, or century). "Trading," meanwhile, means switching stocks during the period with the aim of exceeding the mere "investment" return. (There is no other reason to trade.)
Investing in a diversified portfolio of stocks is usually a positive-sum game: stocks usually go up, and when they do, "investors" make money. The only way to exceed the "investment return," meanwhile, is to buy good stocks and sell bad ones. If a trader does this well, he or she will exceed the market (or "investment") return. Stocks have to be owned by someone, though--even bad stocks--and the trader who bought the bad stocks from the better trader will lag the investment return. In a case in which there are only two traders, the winning trader will exceed the market return by exactly the amount that the losing trader lags it (before costs).
In an essay called "The Arithmetic of Active Management," professor William Sharpe explains the phenomenon this way: The gross return of all traders in a market must equal the market return. If the market goes up 10%, in other words, the gross return of all traders must also be 10% (assuming they all remain fully invested and don't keep some percentage of their portfolio in cash, which is another "market").
To apply this to the reader's example above, let's assume that the "investment return" of the stock in question is $5 (the move from $5 to $10). Assuming the reader held the stock for the entire period, he or she would have made $5. If instead of holding the stock for the entire period, however, the reader tried to exceed the "investment return" by trading the stock back and forth with another trader, the gross return of both traders would still equal $5. Depending on the relative skill (or luck) of the traders, however, the return of each particular trader might be very different: One trader might make $3 while the other made $2. Or one might make $5 while the other made $0. Or one might make $10 while the other lost $5.
What the Slate reader is missing, in other words, is the distinction between "investing" and "trading." In the U.S. stock market over the past century or so, the "investing return" has been about 10% a year. The aggregate "trading" return, meanwhile, has been 10% less the costs of trading. Because it is impossible for the aggregate "trading" return to exceed the "investing" return, every dollar that has been won by one U.S. stock trader has been lost by another.
Technically, then, trading is not zero sum. But it has a lower sum than investing (i.e. trading's sum is mean return minus trading fees, while investing's sum is mean return minus one-time round trip trading fees)
Posted by: Trader | June 11, 2008 at 08:20 PM
we believe we will find more hot stocks, stock pick winners and penny stock winners than ever before and more than anyone else on the Internet. www.speculatingStocks.com
Posted by: Penny Stocks | December 04, 2008 at 02:58 AM
Earn $1000 per day working from the comforts of your home! Save gas, time, and money. Start the new year off with a bang!
http://www.cbsoftware.info
Posted by: software | December 18, 2008 at 12:56 AM
I think that most penny stocks are scams. When trading penny stocks, it's important to realize that most are worthless. It doesn't mean you cannot make money.
You have to go into them realizing they are not investments and you have to sell when you realize the profit you want, because if you don't, you will be left with nothing.
I normally visit this
Penny Stocks Site: http://www.surefirepennystocks.com to research. It's a decent resource.
I know that in penny stocks, they move with good news, chatter online, and when price and volume breakout occurs, you hop in. When the momoentum slows down - GET OUT! Take your profits and limit your losses, that's the way to make money with them
Posted by: Louis | March 01, 2009 at 09:28 AM
Now this is very interesting, impressive and never thought of. In simple words well done for providing creative information.
Posted by: Jeff Paul Internet Millions | March 09, 2009 at 02:58 AM
i really like this post.. thanks
Posted by: Buy Kamagra | March 20, 2009 at 12:21 AM
Stock market is not a Zero-Sum game, read more...
http://tradingandriskmanagement.blogspot.com/2009/05/stock-market-is-not-zero-sum-game.html
Posted by: Rahul | May 20, 2009 at 05:00 AM
penis enlargement products and penis enlargement reviews that discover top penis size enlargement pills, patches, oils and devices that gain 1-3 inches gain in your penis size at www.penissizeenlargement.net
Posted by: penis enlargement | July 11, 2009 at 06:39 AM
penis enlargement products and penis enlargement reviews that discover top penis size enlargement pills, patches, oils and devices that gain 1-3 inches gain in your penis size at www.penissizeenlargement.net
Posted by: penis enlargement | July 11, 2009 at 09:57 AM
Are you ashamed of your small size penis? here is the top penis enlargement methods and penis enlargement products that enlarge penis size naturally in weeks at www.Naturalherbalz.com
Posted by: penis enlargement | July 12, 2009 at 02:00 PM
This is gonna huge, i just cant belive it that i am standing at a great blog of my life, i am really glad to have my comment here in very decent topic. thanks to webmaster.
Posted by: Acomplia | July 20, 2009 at 04:53 PM
hello webmaster! i am really appreciating you for your kindness that you have made a really interesting blog and pick all the great topics for which peoples are always seeking to get information and share their ideas. Great work Man and keep it going. God bless you!
Posted by: enlarge penis | July 31, 2009 at 03:44 PM
This is one of the best blog, i have ever seen in my life, really impressive work by webmatser, i must wanna share my views about this posting, that very low rang of people talk about this in public forum so hats off to blogger. thnx.
Posted by: penis enhancement | August 06, 2009 at 01:23 PM
Rimonabant (also known as Zimulti, Acomplia, Slimona or Obitone) is an anorectic anti obesity drug. It is a CB1 cannabinoid receptor antagonist. Rimonabant has been found to stop food craving enough to help people lose weight, and could also help curb other unhealthy urges, such as smoking. www.genericacomplia.us
Posted by: Acomplia | August 08, 2009 at 05:52 PM
Hair Loss Treatments - Products Cures and Solutions Guide. Read the Hair Loss Guide - Know about Causes, Treatments, Solutions and hairstyles for Men and Women at www.Managehairloss.com
Posted by: Hair loss | August 16, 2009 at 05:47 PM
Penis Enlargement ; The top-rated penis enlargement device. Penis enlargement science easy fast and safe penis enlargement at www.penissizeenlargement.net
Posted by: Natural Penis Enlargement | August 19, 2009 at 03:49 PM
Nice blog, its great article informative post, thanks for sharing it. Thanks for the information!
Posted by: youtube videos | December 03, 2009 at 04:35 PM
I agree that interest rate is very important to stock markets, but there are markets' own trends too.
Posted by: Penny Stocks | December 17, 2009 at 06:22 AM
It is really posted well and it is appreciative. Thanks
Posted by: Penny Stocks | December 28, 2009 at 06:19 AM
It's really great to post my comments on such a blog. I would like to appreciate the great work done by the web master and would like to tell everyone that they should post their interesting comments and should make this blog interesting. Once again I would like to say keep it up to blog owner!!!! http://www.naturalherbalsinc.com
Posted by: Penis Enlargement | January 07, 2010 at 01:54 AM
In the evening I usually save all interesting for me articles and read them either in the morning on my way to work or during the dinner break. When I fail to find free time though, I find http://www.pdfqueen.com set of articles in pdf format and download them
Posted by: Rashad | February 09, 2010 at 11:10 AM
The common stocks which are traded over OTC Bulletin Board or pink sheets carrying per share value of $5 or under that are known as penny stocks. They bear absolute low value and carry limited liquidity.
Posted by: Penny Stocks | May 07, 2010 at 07:39 AM
Do you desire a house but you lack enough cash to acquire it?
Posted by: RamonGustav | August 23, 2010 at 09:45 AM
There are many ways to earn money but i like the trading business. LAst week i have invested $1100 in Madpennystocks.com and within just 6days i will get back $2356. to know how i will get this log in to the website.
Posted by: Malcom Wagon | September 28, 2010 at 07:14 AM
The future of penny stocks and penny stock investing is very bright. It is varying and the people that are going to make funds are the ones that settle in to it. Log on to the website to access more: http://www.hototc.com/
Posted by: Mathew Hidden | October 14, 2010 at 05:21 AM